Home / Blog / Kitchen
Kitchen

Gas vs Electric Ovens: Which One Actually Breaks More Often?

7 min read  ·  Written by our Taunton repair technicians

We repair both every week, and the honest answer might surprise you. Here's what tends to go wrong with each, and how repair costs typically compare.

Gas vs Electric Ovens: Which One Actually Breaks More Often?

Gas Ovens: What Fails Most

Gas ovens rely on an igniter to open the gas valve and light the burner. Igniters wear out gradually — a burner that takes several tries to light, or clicks without lighting at all, is almost always this single, relatively inexpensive part.

Electric Ovens: What Fails Most

Electric ovens depend on a heating element that can visibly show wear — bubbling, blistering, or a bright glowing spot on the coil is a clear sign it's failing and close to burning through completely.

So Which Breaks More Often?

In our experience, electric ovens see slightly more service calls overall, mostly because they have more electrical components — igniters aren't a factor, but control boards, sensors, and multiple heating elements (bake and broil) each introduce their own failure points.

Repair Cost Comparison

A gas igniter replacement tends to be one of the more affordable oven repairs. Electric heating elements are similarly affordable, but electric ovens are more likely to need a control board repair down the line, which typically costs more than either of those parts.

What This Means for Your Household

Neither type is meaningfully less reliable than the other over its full lifespan — the difference is mainly in what breaks and how noticeable the symptom is. A gas oven usually announces its failure clearly through ignition trouble, while electric ovens can develop subtler issues first.

Quick Answer

Electric ovens see slightly more repair calls due to having more electrical components, but gas oven igniter failures are more noticeable and usually cheaper to fix.

How It Gets Fixed

How This Gets Repaired, Step by Step

If the checks above don't resolve it, here's exactly what happens when you call us for this issue.

1

Call & Describe the Issue

Call (508) 464-9173 and describe exactly what you're seeing — the more detail you give, the faster we can bring the right parts on the first visit.

2

On-Site Diagnosis

A technician inspects the appliance in person and confirms the actual cause, rather than guessing from symptoms alone, using the same checks covered in this guide plus manufacturer-specific testing.

3

Written Estimate Before Any Work

You approve a clear, upfront price before anything is repaired or replaced — no surprise charges once the job is underway.

4

Repaired & Backed by a 90-Day Warranty

The appliance is tested to confirm the issue is fully resolved, and every repair is backed by a 90-day warranty on parts and labor.

Common Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

What Taunton homeowners usually ask about this exact issue.

It's not dangerous by itself, but it does mean gas is being released briefly each time without igniting. If clicking continues for more than a few seconds without lighting, turn off the burner and have the igniter checked.
It's a straightforward part to access on many models, but it does involve working near electrical connections inside the oven, so we'd recommend a technician handle it unless you're comfortable with basic appliance electrical work.
A slow preheat is one of the earliest signs of a weakening heating element, even before it shows visible damage — it's worth mentioning to a technician if you're already having something else looked at.
Yes, dual-fuel ranges combine a gas cooktop's igniter components with an electric oven's heating element, so they can develop either type of issue independently.

Still not sure what's causing the problem? A five-minute call is often faster than troubleshooting alone.

(508) 464-9173
Still Not Sure What's Wrong?

Skip the Guesswork — Talk to a Technician

Articles are a great starting point, but same-day dishwasher repair in Taunton is one call away.

(508) 464-9173
Taunton, MA  |  Mon–Fri 7AM–7PM, Sat 8AM–5PM
Call Now — Same-Day Service